3 Common Mistakes in Church Capital Campaigns & How to Avoid Them

At Servant Keeper, we understand that a successful church capital campaign requires careful planning and execution. There are no shortcuts, but you can avoid common pitfalls to set your church up for success. Whether you're preparing for a campaign, crafting a landing page, or in the midst of one, here are three critical mistakes to sidestep, with tips to leverage Servant Keeper’s giving, reporting, and dashboard tools to make your campaign thrive.

1. Ignoring Storytelling

People of all ages are drawn to stories. As Jonathan Gottschall says, “Even when the body goes to sleep, the mind stays up all night, telling itself stories.” Harness the power of storytelling in your church’s capital campaign.

While practical details—like the amount needed, how funds will be used, and project timelines—are essential, don’t overlook the emotional impact of stories. Use pictures and videos in your presentations and updates. A simple smartphone video can capture attention and stay memorable in ways numbers alone cannot.

Paint vivid pictures with your words. For example, describe how a new building will become a space where children learn about God for the first time, or share stories of lives transformed through a missionary’s work. With Servant Keeper’s dashboard tools, you can track engagement and share these stories effectively to keep your congregation inspired.

2. Focusing Solely on Numbers

Numbers matter, but context makes them meaningful. Saying “We raised $1,000 yesterday” doesn’t resonate unless you know the goal is within reach, like being just $1,500 away. Show progress, not just numbers.

Instead of a traditional cardboard thermometer, use Servant Keeper’s reporting tools to create a digital progress tracker. With our dashboard, you can display real-time updates as donations roll in, keeping your congregation engaged whether they’re in the sanctuary or following along online. No mess, no last-minute updates—just a clear, exciting visual of your campaign’s momentum.

3. Overlooking Roadblocks to Giving

Even a perfectly planned campaign can falter if giving is difficult. Ensure your campaign fund is easy to access with a direct link on your church website, in relevant emails and text messages, and in newsletters, so donors always have a way to give at their fingertips. Servant Keeper’s communication tools and church app make this easy.

Ask yourself:

• Is it easy for people to give immediately upon hearing about the campaign?
• Can they give easily over time, weeks or months later?

For in-person services, set up your own giving station with Servant Keeper. All you need is a tablet to create a modern, hands-on giving experience, replacing the traditional offering plate without requiring cash or checks.

For both in-person and online services, enable mobile giving and text-to-give options through Servant Keeper’s platform. Most people have their phones handy, so make giving as simple as a tap. For live-streamed services, add a giving button directly on your website’s streaming page.

For those who need time to review their budgets, Servant Keeper supports:

• Online giving
• Mobile giving
• Recurring giving

These options ensure giving is accessible and convenient, whether someone donates on the spot or plans their contribution later.

By avoiding these three mistakes—ignoring storytelling, focusing only on numbers, and overlooking giving roadblocks—you can run a smoother, more effective capital campaign. With Servant Keeper’s giving, reporting, and dashboard tools, you have everything you need to inspire generosity and track progress with ease.

‍